Epicurious Videos
- Go to Epicurious.com
-
Subscribe to 'Epicurious' on YouTube to keep up with all of our latest videos and shows.
When autocomplete results are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to select.
4 Levels of Ice Cream Sundaes: Amateur to Food Scientist
We challenged chefs of three different levels - an amateur, a home cook and a professional chef - to make their versions of an ice cream sundae. And then we brought in a food scientist to review their work. Which sundae was the best? Check out the professional's recipe here on the ICE blog: https://www.ice.edu/blog/banana-passionfruit-gelato-recipe
Released on 6/17/2019
Transcript
00:00
[chopping] [pouring]
00:01
[sizzling] [slicing]
00:02
[mixing]
00:03
[upbeat music]
00:06
I'm Stephen, and I'm a level one chef.
00:07
I'm Beth, and I'm a level two chef.
00:10
I'm Rory Macdonald,
00:11
and I've been a chef for over 12 years.
00:12
[upbeat music]
00:14
This is my ice cream recipe that I created.
00:16
I needed something to comfort me on those lonely nights,
00:19
and this is how we're gonna mend a broken heart.
00:21
This is inspired by the banana split,
00:23
but certainly with a Damiano family twist.
00:26
This is my recipe for banana and passion fruit gelato.
00:28
It's one of my favorite recipes
00:29
that we use in the dessert bar.
00:31
[whooshing]
00:33
[pointer clicking] [suspenseful music]
00:34
[bell dinging]
00:38
So we're gonna start with the caramel corn ice cream.
00:40
There's kind of already a cheat code.
00:42
You have your cone, you have your chocolate,
00:44
you have your caramel.
00:45
Let's just jump into it.
00:46
I'm gonna start by making vanilla bean ice cream.
00:49
And we're gonna start with some heavy cream.
00:52
We're gonna start this gelato by making
00:53
a really simple sorbet syrup.
00:55
First thing we're gonna add
00:56
is sugar. Lots of sugar.
00:56
Because you can't have ice cream without sugar.
00:59
Always a pinch of salt.
01:01
Water, and lastly, trimoline,
01:02
also know by pastry chefs as invert sugar.
01:03
There's a mixture of glucose and fructose.
01:06
Take your big spoon, and scoop it out.
01:09
I scooped out around half of it.
01:11
That's why I'm a level one, I can't tell you the ounces.
01:14
Now what I like to do to make it vanilla bean, certainly,
01:17
is to use a vanilla bean.
01:19
Slice the bean down the middle.
01:21
So I'm just gonna put the whole thing in
01:23
because I'm gonna strain it.
01:24
You're gonna stir, stir, stir.
01:26
Now that everything's dissolved,
01:28
I'm just gonna put this on the side
01:30
so that it can steep and cool down a little bit,
01:32
so that I can add it to my eggs.
01:34
And then we're gonna take the chocolate,
01:38
like so, the chocolate brownies.
01:41
So this has come to the boil.
01:43
We're gonna take this off now and allow it to cool.
01:45
And then we're gonna continue
01:46
biding the bananas and the passion fruit.
01:48
So we're gonna cut the banana in half, lengthwise.
01:50
Carefully scrape out all the middle of the seeds.
01:52
If you remove those seeds you're gonna
01:54
stop the banana going so gray.
01:56
So now we're gonna weigh out the bananas into the beaker.
01:58
Next step, eggs and sugar mixture.
02:01
I'm only gonna use egg yolks,
02:03
we don't really need the whites, and some sugar.
02:06
And I'm gonna mix them together with an electric mixer.
02:09
So you take this utensil,
02:10
which is used to chop up the brownie.
02:13
Now, it's kind of mixed and fused together.
02:16
Everything is working harmoniously.
02:18
That's a word, nailed it.
02:20
So next we're gonna pare the passion fruits.
02:22
So we're just gonna take the top off,
02:23
and then scoop out the seeds.
02:24
And for this recipe we're trying to use
02:26
all of the passion fruit.
02:27
We're using the juice for the sorbet,
02:29
we're gonna use the seeds for a garnish,
02:30
and we're gonna use the husks
02:32
to actually present the sorbet in.
02:33
Bring my egg yolk mixture into my cream mixture,
02:37
and I wanna whisk until the mixture gets to be
02:39
at least lukewarm.
02:41
So you mix up your M&Ms.
02:42
I came up with this method because
02:44
caramel corn has almost everything I want,
02:47
but it didn't have the M&Ms
02:48
and the brownies inside of it,
02:50
so I went ahead and fixed that.
02:51
And now I actually perfected it.
02:53
They can hire me if they want.
02:55
And I'm gonna pour it into the strainer,
02:58
over a larger bowl filled with ice water.
03:00
I want to really cool down this mixture
03:03
before I put it into the ice cream machine.
03:05
So next step is we're gonna add
03:07
the rest of the ingredients to the beaker.
03:09
Passion fruit juice, lemon juice, and a little bit of cream,
03:11
and lastly we're gonna add our sorbet syrup that we made.
03:14
We are so much closer to ice cream now.
03:17
I use a Kitchen Aid ice cream maker attachment,
03:20
and I'm gonna start pouring my custard
03:23
right into the ice cream maker.
03:25
I need to leave it on for 30 minutes.
03:27
I feel like there's a easier way to go about this,
03:29
but it tastes better this way.
03:30
It's all about the end product.
03:33
You want to keep it in the freezer for at least 4 hours.
03:36
Off to the freezer. We're gonna freeze it solid.
03:36
And once it's totally set,
03:38
we're gonna add it to the Paco Jet machine.
03:40
It has a really powerful blade,
03:42
which basically will make liquids solids,
03:43
anything into a puree.
03:45
And that looks good.
03:46
It's ready to go.
03:47
Now we wanna plate it.
03:48
This is like mush, but it tastes good.
03:51
So our fruit mixture is now frozen solid.
03:53
Now we're ready to spin this in the Paco Jet.
03:55
The blade is attached underneath.
03:57
And now when we turn it on,
03:58
basically the blade is gonna force its way down,
04:00
and it's basically gonna puree that frozen mixture.
04:02
Paco Jet generally takes between two and three minutes
04:04
to finish a cycle.
04:05
Now if you see, we have a perfect texture.
04:09
Now, we're gonna add our hot fudge.
04:11
I'm gonna heat it up, and I'll be back in a minute.
04:12
We're gonna keep this in the freezer.
04:14
Now we're gonna make our passion fruit
04:15
caramel sauce. Caramel sauce.
04:16
And this is the easiest, most delicious
04:18
caramel sauce you can make.
04:20
I'm gonna start with half and half,
04:21
some light brown sugar, butter, and a pinch of salt.
04:25
So in here we have sugar and glucose.
04:27
So this is gonna come to a boil,
04:29
it's gonna turn a dark caramel color.
04:31
It's gonna take about five or 10 minutes.
04:32
And I just keep stirring 'til everything is soft
04:35
and melted together and smells delicious.
04:38
I'm gonna add my vanilla,
04:40
and I'm actually gonna cook it for another minute more.
04:43
After that we're gonna add the butter
04:44
to stop the caramel of cooking.
04:46
Next up is the cream.
04:48
The cream is really for texture,
04:49
and gives the right consistency we want for a caramel sauce.
04:51
You can tell it's ready
04:52
because the texture is a lot thicker.
04:54
And now we're ready to add our fresh passion fruit juice.
04:56
I'm gonna bring that back to the boil
04:57
for another two to three minutes.
04:59
I suppose you could keep this in the fridge
05:01
for a couple of weeks,
05:02
but it never lasts more than a day or two in my house.
05:06
Warm caramel, it's wonderful.
05:09
Nice and warm.
05:10
We're gonna add our hot fudge.
05:12
Oh that's perfect.
05:13
This is exactly how you want it to look.
05:15
[upbeat music]
05:17
We're gonna add the passion fruit seeds.
05:18
We add it at the end because we really want to have
05:20
a fresh passion fruit flavor,
05:21
and we don't want that to boil off.
05:23
Now we're gonna take off the heat and allow it to cool.
05:26
And now on to the toppings. Now the toppings.
05:28
Sprinkle a few extra ingredients on.
05:31
So you wanna break up the brownie.
05:33
So of course we have to start with whipped cream.
05:35
[mixer whirs]
05:36
Whip the cream.
05:37
Our gelato's out the freezer already.
05:39
Now we're gonna scoop, and add the toppings.
05:41
Here's our vanilla bean ice cream that we made earlier.
05:44
The most important thing to remember about a good sundae
05:47
is that there is no such thing as too much.
05:50
More is not more, it's better.
05:53
And then the M&Ms just to give it some color.
05:55
More of a garnishment at this point.
05:57
So now we're adding some passion fruit seeds to the top
05:59
as a garnish, but again these do have flavor.
06:01
They also have a nice crunchy texture.
06:03
Our freshly-made caramel sauce.
06:06
We're also gonna add some of this
06:07
dehydrated passion fruit,
06:08
which again gives it a really nice flavor,
06:10
but also gives it a crunchy texture.
06:11
Chopped, wet walnuts.
06:14
[Rory] And then we're just gonna finish it off
06:15
with a little micro red amaranth.
06:17
It's a micro herb.
06:19
Nice chopped bananas.
06:20
[Stephen] Some whipped cream to top it off.
06:24
You continuously put whipped cream on.
06:26
That's why the bowl is right on the table.
06:28
Because this much whipped cream is not enough.
06:30
[Stephen] Always counterclockwise.
06:33
[playful music] [whipped cream spraying]
06:38
Sprinkles for my Lukey Luke,
06:40
my grandson who loves sprinkles.
06:42
And two cherries.
06:44
A little bit more brownies.
06:46
A little color.
06:47
Don't be stingy.
06:48
Hm, maybe three.
06:50
And it's the perfect level of melted.
06:52
Boom.
06:52
[camera shutter clicks]
06:53
A perfect sundae.
06:54
[camera shutter clicks] [bright music]
06:56
This is my banana passion fruit gelato
06:58
with a passion fruit caramel sauce.
06:59
[camera shutter clicks]
07:01
[bright music]
07:05
Time for the taste test.
07:08
Heaven in a bowl.
07:09
Oh that's mostly whipped cream.
07:11
So good.
07:11
Let's do that again.
07:13
[bright music]
07:14
It's pretty good.
07:16
The caramel sauce is so wonderful
07:18
on this vanilla bean ice cream.
07:19
It's so fresh and so light.
07:21
The tartness of the passion fruit
07:23
really cuts through the richness of the banana,
07:24
and the texture on the top
07:25
just really complements everything.
07:26
But we gotta get some brownie.
07:28
[bright music]
07:29
Again with the whipped cream.
07:31
Don't use as much whipped cream as I did.
07:33
If I made this again, I would add more whipped cream.
07:36
[chuckles]
07:37
Maybe chocolate sauce.
07:38
And now the chocolate is basically
07:40
layering the roof of my mouth, so maybe less brownies,
07:44
two less brownies though.
07:45
This gelato's fantastic in the summer
07:47
when it's really hot and humid to help you guys cool down.
07:50
Other than more, I'm not sure I'd make it differently.
07:53
Like I do with most things in my life,
07:54
you start something, you gotta finish it.
07:56
[bright music]
07:57
That's good.
07:58
[rock music]
07:59
Our chefs used three different kinds
08:01
of ice cream in their sundaes.
08:03
Stephen used a commercially-made store-bought ice cream.
08:06
You guys should have a pre-k 'cause
08:08
I'm not even at level one.
08:09
Beth used a homemade custard-style ice cream.
08:12
Kinda like a banana split, but with my twist on it.
08:16
And Rory used a mixture of gelato and sorbet.
08:20
Gelato has different interpretations for different people.
08:22
[suspenseful music]
08:26
Milk fat gives ice cream a creamy and smooth mouth feel,
08:30
and a buttery and rich flavor.
08:32
Stephen's ice cream contains about 10 to 14% milk fat,
08:36
which is going to contribute to the ice cream's smoothness
08:39
and overall mouth feel.
08:40
The custard-style ice cream that Beth made
08:43
has a higher amount of milk fat than the store-bought kind.
08:46
This is gonna give it a creamier and smoother taste.
08:49
Nice and thick and creamy.
08:51
Rory'a gelato-style ice cream
08:53
uses a combination of cream and pureed fruit.
08:56
This has less milk fat than we find
08:59
in our commercially-available or custard-style ice cream,
09:02
and it's gonna give it a less creamy mouth feel.
09:05
Sugar provides flavor and texture to ice cream.
09:08
Commercially-bought ice cream has about 14 to 15% sugar,
09:12
and this was similar in Beth's ice cream.
09:14
Because that makes it taste the best.
09:16
Rory's gelato-style ice cream used trimoline,
09:20
which is a liquid sugar made from sucrose
09:22
that has been inverted, or split into glucose and fructose.
09:28
Glucose and fructose are both monosaccharides
09:30
that freeze at even lower temperatures than regular sugar.
09:34
This provides a sweeter flavor to the ice cream,
09:37
and will also allow it to be softer at frozen temperatures.
09:41
[suspenseful music]
09:45
Ice cream is churned to incorporate air,
09:47
and to freeze the product.
09:49
Commercially-made ice cream is whipped with air
09:52
to about 75% or 100% of the total ice cream mixture.
09:56
This means that commercially-bought ice cream
09:59
has about one to one ratio of ice cream to air.
10:02
The custard-style ice cream that Beth made
10:05
has less overrun, or air incorporated into it
10:08
compared to our commercial-style ice cream.
10:11
The structure of frozen desserts is greatly dependent
10:14
on the amount of ice crystal formation we get
10:16
when the water freezes.
10:18
The ice crystals start to form as we freeze the ice cream,
10:21
and the slower we freeze it and churn it,
10:23
we get large ice crystals.
10:25
Perfect for my sundaes.
10:27
Rory used a Paco Jet to make his gelato-style ice cream.
10:31
The Paco Jet spins with the ice cream inside very rapidly,
10:35
which helps to minimize the amount
10:37
of ice crystal formation we see,
10:38
and makes a smooth ice cream.
10:41
[suspenseful music]
10:44
Stephen used a store-bought fudge sauce.
10:47
Nice and warm.
10:47
Beth and Rory both used a homemade caramel sauce.
10:51
Beth combined all of the ingredients up front,
10:54
and cooked it over the heat
10:55
until the caramel became deep in color
10:58
with a rich and creamy flavor.
10:59
Immediately it looks like caramel sauce.
11:03
Rory heated his sugar first
11:05
to produce a caramelization reaction.
11:07
That never quite works for me.
11:09
This is a non-enzymatic browning reaction,
11:12
where the sugars that Rory used came in contact with heat,
11:15
and started to turn brown, or turn into caramel.
11:18
He then added butter and cream into his caramelized sugar
11:23
to stop the caramelization reaction
11:25
to produce a creamy and viscous sauce.
11:28
So it got a little steamy in there for a while,
11:30
but now the texture has thickened, and now I know it's done.
11:32
[suspenseful music]
11:35
Our chefs used different toppings
11:37
and mix-ins in their sundaes.
11:39
Stephen used M&Ms and brownies mixed into his ice cream,
11:43
and whipped cream on top.
11:45
Beth used wet walnuts, bananas, whipped cream,
11:48
sprinkles, cherries, all on top of her sundae.
11:52
It's not a sundae without the cherries.
11:54
Rory used plain passion fruit seeds
11:56
and dehydrated passion fruit.
11:58
Low-moisture mix-ins and toppings,
12:00
like brownies or M&Ms, or those passion fruit seeds,
12:04
won't freeze when they touch the ice cream,
12:06
and they will be easy to chew when you eat your sundae.
12:09
Which is nice for the gelato, 'cause it's soft.
12:11
High-moisture mix-ins, like bananas,
12:13
might start to freeze when they touch the sundae,
12:16
and will be a little bit grittier or sandier to chew
12:19
when you eat your ice cream sundae.
12:20
You put out the toppings,
12:22
and everybody makes their own choices.
12:25
[suspenseful music]
12:28
Commercially-bought ice cream uses egg yolks,
12:31
or xanthan gum, carrageenan, or any type of food gum
12:35
to bind the milk fat and the water,
12:37
which is going to help to keep the ice cream
12:39
cold at room temperature for a longer amount of time.
12:42
But Stephen manipulated his ice cream at room temperature,
12:46
so even though the ice cream contains stabilizers,
12:49
it's still going to melt at room temperature.
12:51
And that looks good, that looks ready to go.
12:53
Taste perception decreases
12:55
in extreme hot or cold environments.
12:58
Melted ice cream might taste sweeter
13:00
than very cold ice cream.
13:02
You should try it for yourself.
13:03
Remember, microwave, a minute,
13:04
a minute 30 seconds if you wanna be like Steve.
13:07
Beth's product had a fairly low sugar content
13:11
compared to our commercially-made ice cream,
13:13
and also contained a lot of emulsifiers,
13:16
or stabilizers in the egg yolks.
13:18
This is going to help to keep the ice cream colder,
13:21
or more frozen, and melt less quickly.
13:24
And in Rory's ice cream, he didn't use
13:26
any type of stabilizer or emulsifier.
13:29
This is going to produce a really creamy final product,
13:33
but upon storage, the ice cream will become
13:35
a little bit hard and sandy.
13:38
Next time you're craving something sweet,
13:40
take something that you learned here today
13:42
and incorporate that into your own sundae.
13:45
[bright music]